Showing posts with label Spinner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Spinner. Show all posts

Tuesday, 1 February 2022

New Spinner - 2 of 2

Once I got the rough spinner from Catto, next task was to make the prop cutouts and screw holes. One of the reasons of my spinner replacement was improper tracking so I really wanted to emphasize on a precise tracking for this new one.

I found this interesting article on the EAA website on spinners. It explains how to make a blade cut-out template. I did try a few ways of making a template by using cardboard or scrap aluminum but I found it difficult to make an accurate and easy to use template on top of this double-curved surface.

The old spinner had the same diameter and length as the new one. The shape looked very similar so I tried using a piece of the old fiberglass spinner to make a blade cut-out template. I used a dremel with a thin cutting disk for all the rough cutting, including in the carbon fiber for the cutouts described later on. 


When putting the piece on top of the new spinner surface, it did match the shape pretty well. I therefore decided to use it as my template material. I used my cardboard template attempt to trace the rough lines on the fiberglass template:


The curved line above shows the actual shape of the back end surface of the prop. It became clear that cutting this shape would make the spinner impossible to install, so I thought a line parallel to the forward cut was a good compromise.

Then a rather long iterative process began. With the new spinner aft bulkhead, prop and old spinner forward bulkhead installed on the engine, I made gradual adjustments to the template until reaching a cut-out with a 1/8 inch prop clearance. I could firmly hold the template against the bulkheads using side grip clamps and Cleco pins. I used a Sharpie pen to mark the areas where material removal was needed.  Then to remove material I used a curved file and most importantly, patience.

After 2 hours of back-and-forth, I finally ended up with a template I was happy with. The picture below shows the template on top of the new spinner:


I used the template to mark both cutouts on the new spinner using a fine point pen. Then I carefully cut offset cutouts with the Dremel and then refined the cutout to match the lines using a file. When trying to fit the new spinner in place, I realized the centering dowel was preventing the spinner to fully get in its position. I initially thought it was just long enough to fit in the prop crushplate. It was in fact longer than that and designed to get also into the prop hub. My Prince prop having only a 1 inch diameter center hole vs the 2.25 inch dowel diameter, I had to find an alternative. After a confirmation call with the friendly staff at Catto, I decided to shorten the dowel to ensure the spinner could slide all the way aft until reaching the bulkhead, while still performing its self-centering in the crushplate:



This allowed me to get a final fit on the airplane. I did have to make very small adjustments to the cutouts, probably due to the effect of the template thickness, but nothing compared to the making of the template itself.

For tracking, I simply used a piece of MDF wood clamped on a trestle as a ground reference. As recommended in the EAA article, I removed one spark plug per cylinder to freely rotate the prop. The centering dowel made the tracking exercise fairly easy. Only had to make small adjustments to find the symmetrical position and mark crew holes:


I was then ready for clear coat! I could have painted it black like the old spinner, but I thought a clear coat on carbon fiber was going to make a good match with the CF weaves on the Prince prop.

Since I hate painting, I sent the spinner to a good paint shop. Really anxious to get it back!

Stay tuned for the final look and final weight numbers.

Wednesday, 19 January 2022

New Spinner - 1 of 2

During an acro practice session last summer, a friend of mine was looking at my airplane while I was starting the engine and pointed out that my spinner was wobbling. The wobbling motion appeared to be due to an improper tracking. This was a very valuable observation since I never got to see my spinner turning myself.

I was sometimes missing a spinner screw after a flight, despite using loctite and locking nutplates. Vibrations due to this improper tracking were probably the main root cause. These were signs that the spinner was due for a change. Loosing a spinner in flight can really become a catastrophic scenario. So I began making some research. As I am looking to shift the CG back on this airplane since it is nose-heavy, I was also looking at the opportunity to save weight.

No matter what spinner I chose, I was going to need a dynamic re-balancing. I therefore decided to buy the Skydynamics featherweight flywheel and change my flywheel at the same time. 

Next was the spinner itself. My old spinner was made of fiberglass with two aluminum bulikheads. I can't say for sure what type it is, but it appears to be the Vans 13-inch spinner. 

First thing I did was to remove spinner and prop to get the actual weight of my spinner assembly. Turned out to be 3lb 8.6 oz including bulkheads and hardware.

I contacted Rob Millinship at aerographic in UK since I knew they were making nice CF spinners. Rob said they focused on sturdiness and that their spinner weighed probably more than a standard aluminum spinner...

I didn't find tons of info on the web on other spinner weights. Here are a few from Aircraft Spruce:


SN4 spinner kit (most likely discontinued):




BN-3 spinner kit (also most likely discontinued):




Catto spinners:




Vans spinner: no weight information on their website, but according to friends on the Biplane Forum, the new assembly weighs about 2lb 14 oz + hardware, so about 3 lb total. 

Also looked at other types, but couldn't find weight info on them or were not adapted to my installation.

Catto was more expensive, but appeared to be the lightest option. What I also found interesting is their fwd bulkhead design: it is glued and has a self-centering dowel helping for proper tracking:



The dowel is designed to fit into the crushplate center hole. It has a 2.25 inch dia and appears to be slightly tapered to ensure a snug fit.

For the above reasons, I opted for the Catto spinner and got great service from the team at Catto.

Once I received the spinner assembly from Catto, I couldn't resist to weigh it to compare with my old spinner. In summary:

  • Old 13 inch spinner: 3lb 8.6 oz
  • New catto 13 inch spinner: 2lb 4.0 oz (rough i.e. no clear coat and no prop cutouts)
  • Old lycoming flywheel (with grinded alternator pulley): 5lb 6.8 oz
  • New Skydynamics featherweight: 3lb 2.7oz

...overall these changes may take more than 3.5 lb off the nose! Weight saving there is like killing 3 birds with 1 stone: less loads on the crankshaft during tumbling maneuvers, less forward CG clipping and less weight!

This is promising...

Next post will be about the prop cutouts and tracking (hopefully better than the old spinner!)